Reading fluently versus accurately

Schools often monitor and emphasize fluency building exercises to the detriment of decoding skills. One popular tool they use is called “DIBELS,” which has the child read a grade-level passage and measures how quickly they read it. Schools often see from this tool that there is a reading problem, but then only emphasize instruction to correct the fluency problem. However, this does not fix the root cause of the problem, which could be lack of decoding skills, lack of phonemic awareness, or any number of auditory/speech problems. If students are guessing at words based on context, which is what most fluency instruction asks them to do, they are likely to miss the meaning of the text. A child cannot read for comprehension if their decoding skills are not up to the task. We emphasize decoding skills first and foremost, and as a secondary skill we work on fluency using controlled text the student can decode. A student with dyslexia may or may not get to be as fast a reader as their peers, but they can certainly learn to be an accurate reader and thus get the information needed from text.

Leave a Reply